Scenario Planning: Civil Society Responses to Far Right Authoritarianism

By

A scenario planning tool for civil society organisations affected by the rise of far right authoritarianism. This tool can help people understand their current context, plan for potential futures, and take strategic steps.

Introduction

This is a scenario planning tool for civil society organisations concerned about whether they have the right strategies in place given the rise of the authoritarian far right and the influence it is already having.

The tool was developed by Jim Coe, UK social movement researcher and consultant. Jim Coe and Natasha Adams have convened gatherings; undertaken research; and produced reports investigating the impact of the far right on civil society organisations, and the range of potential responses.

In their report, Towards Meaningful Action: NGOs’ responses to threats from far-right authoritarianism, Coe and Adams emphasise the need to take substantive steps across a range of areas: Building a collective response; Organisations’ capabilities and preparedness; and Organisational strategy.

A diagram outlining areas of response to the authoritarian far right: Building a collective response; Organisational strategy; and Organisations' capabilities and preparedness.

The problem we are facing is that a far-right, authoritarian political party is increasingly gaining access to power and could potentially form a future government, but also that the influence of the far-right is already permeating government and other policy, discourse, and spaces for influence. – Towards Meaningful Action, 2026

The scenario planning tool can be used by NGOs to understand the situation, develop greater preparedness, define red lines and protocols, and inform strategy and collective responses.

Diagnosis and Prognosis

For each theme, pick the column most relevant to your assessment of:

  • (a) the context now,
  • (b) what the context will likely be in five years’ time.

In relation to (b), obviously we don’t know the future, and you might choose to take a more optimistic or pessimistic position. Either way, the purpose of the exercise is to allow you to ensure that you have made sensible strategic provision for what is likely to be a difficult context, one that may require different strategic approaches to those that may have seemed optimum in the past.

The answers can provide intelligence to help explore potential implications for your work, and to use this thinking to inform your current strategy. 

Theme1234
Conduciveness of the environment on specific issue(s) of concern  to youHealthyMixedPoor but with some limited opportunityHostile, highly negative
Civil society spaceOpen, benignMixed, with some closing down of political space NarrowClosed, characterised by sustained attempts to delegitimise civil society and attack its funding and independence
Extent to which liberties and rights are protectedGoodMixedHighly boundedSustained curtailments, particularly for marginalised groups and centres of perceived opposition
Extent to which democratic institutions are functioningInstitutions of democracy are being radically renewedPatchy, but seemingly stableTrending towards authoritarianismDangerously low, quasi-fascism
Possibilities of open and fair public debatePluralistic marketplace of ideasUneven; biases (eg in ownership of means of communication) mean that certain perspectives dominateScope for reasoned and meaningful debate is very limitedEpistemic collapse, truth is everywhere contested
How most marginalised communities are being impactedThere are meaningful moves towards an equitable societySome discriminatory cultures and practices, and a climate that facilitates themSustained discriminationTargeted onslaughts

Implications

To inform your strategy, given your answers to the above…

Programmes

  1. Do you need to be doing more to help ensure that the communities you work with, and your staff, are safe and secure?
  2. Should you be speaking out (more) about prospective threats to your work?

Influencing Strategies

  1. Do you have the right mix of influencing tactics, messages and targets? If not, how might this shift?
  2. Do you have the right balance between critiquing the political and economic system and trying to work within it?
  3. Should you be more focused on root causes – by addressing the power dynamics that are underpinning these trends, for example?

Focus

  1. Should you be more oriented to cross issue work, rather than solely focusing on your own issue? 
  2. Should you be more involved in work that seeks to protect civil society space, and to protect and build resilient democratic institutions?

Resilience and Survival

  1. Should you be doing more to prepare in terms of how you are set up organisationally, and what a resilient and sustainable organisation might look like in future?
  2. Should you be doing more to invest in a legacy so that, as far as possible, communities you support can claim their rights and protect themselves if your organisation ceases to exist, or ceases to be able to meaningfully support them?

Explore Further


Search